I've been lucky enough to try both and i am a greater fan of Treacle Moon's products because they are more affordable and they are wonderful quality.
The scent of Treacle Moon's range is so true to life.
Coconut Island really does smell of coconut milk, not Malibu like so many other brands adaptations of the coconut scent.
Vanilla is sweet but not sickly and Ginger is a warming but not overpowering.
I have been lucky enough to be sent their new Mango scent to try and it's smells more fresh than the real fruit actually smells. I have no idea how they've done it but they are the most original smelling products i have ever tried.
They don't loose points on how good the shower and bath gel and hand wash makes the skin feel.
The smallest amount of hand wash creates a rich lather and the smell lasts long after washing. The shower gels foam up to create a rich lather also and don't leave the skin lacking in moisture like i would presume a product costing such a bargain price would.